SAML vs. SSO: Key differences and best uses
As digital ecosystems grow more interconnected, managing user access across multiple applications and systems has become a priority for businesses. Single Sign-On (SSO) and Security Assertion Markup Language (SAML) are two critical components of modern authentication frameworks. Both contribute to secure and seamless access, but understanding their distinct roles, how they differ — and how they complement one another — is vital for implementing the right solutions.
Understanding SAML and SSO: Where each fits
Organizations today increasingly rely on secure and efficient authentication methods to manage access to a growing number of applications and systems. Single Sign-On (SSO) and Security Assertion Markup Language (SAML) represent two critical technologies that enable seamless access and robust security in complex digital environments.
While they are often used together, their roles and implementations differ significantly, with SSO mainly focused on user experience while SAML provides the framework for secure identity federation.
As businesses prioritize user convenience and strong data protection, understanding the roles — and limitations — of SSO and SAML is essential for implementing effective identity and access management strategies. Their ability to simplify authentication processes while maintaining strong security measures makes them indispensable in supporting collaboration, productivity, and compliance. Here’s how they stack up.
What is SSO?
Single Sign-On (SSO) is an authentication method that allows users to access multiple applications or systems with a single set of login credentials. Instead of requiring separate logins for each application, SSO enables users to sign in once and gain access to all connected resources within the network.
Key Features of SSO:
Simplified user experience: Users only need to remember one set of credentials, reducing login fatigue and improving productivity.
Centralized authentication: Authentication occurs through a single, central authority, ensuring consistent security policies.
Improved security: By minimizing the number of times users enter credentials, SSO reduces the risk of phishing and credential theft.
Streamlined IT management: IT teams can manage access centrally, reducing administrative overhead and improving oversight.
Example SSO Use Case:
A multinational corporation might implement SSO to allow employees to seamlessly access various cloud applications, such as Slack, Salesforce, and Microsoft Teams, without requiring multiple logins. This integration reduces downtime caused by forgotten passwords while enhancing user satisfaction.
What is SAML?
Security Assertion Markup Language (SAML) is an open standard for exchanging authentication and authorization data between parties, typically an identity provider (IdP) and a service provider (SP). SAML enables secure, token-based communication to confirm user identity and permissions without requiring direct sharing of credentials.
Key Features of SAML:
Federated identity management: SAML facilitates identity federation, allowing users to authenticate once and access resources across multiple organizations or domains.
Interoperability: As an open standard, SAML works across various platforms, applications, and providers, ensuring broad compatibility.
Token-based authentication: SAML uses XML-based tokens to communicate authentication and authorization information, dropping the need for passwords.
Enhanced privacy: User credentials stay with the identity provider and are not shared with service providers, improving security and privacy.
Example SAML Use Case:
A healthcare network that includes hospitals, clinics, and insurance providers might use SAML to enable secure access to shared patient records. Staff members log in through the hospital's identity provider, and SAML tokens authenticate their access to external systems without exposing their credentials.
Why are SSO and SAML sometimes confused?
SSO and SAML are often mentioned together because they are closely related technologies that address overlapping aspects of authentication and access management. However, their roles and implementations are distinct:
Complementary Functions:
SAML is a protocol used to implement SSO functionality. While SSO describes the user experience (one login for multiple applications), SAML provides the framework that enables this by securely exchanging identity information.
Shared Goals
Both aim to improve security, simplify user access, and reduce reliance on multiple passwords. This shared purpose can lead to confusion about where one ends and the other begins.
Common Use Cases
SSO solutions often rely on SAML to authenticate users across systems, making it easy to blur the lines between the two.
Interchangeable Language
In casual conversations, SSO and SAML are sometimes used interchangeably, particularly by non-technical stakeholders who focus on the user-facing benefits rather than the underlying technology.
Overlap with Other Protocols
SSO can also be implemented using other protocols, such as OAuth or OpenID Connect. The frequent pairing of SSO with SAML adds to the perception that they are inseparable.
Understanding the distinctions between SSO and SAML is essential for designing efficient authentication workflows and selecting the right tools for an organization’s needs.
What are the key differences between SSO and SAML?
While SSO and SAML are closely related, they differ in several fundamental ways, including:
Definition
SSO: A method or user experience for accessing multiple systems with one set of credentials.
SAML: A protocol used to exchange authentication and authorization data.
Scope of Use
SSO: Focuses on the user experience and seamless access across multiple applications.
SAML: Ensures secure communication of identity information between systems or domains.
Underlying Technology
SSO: Can be implemented using various protocols, including SAML, OAuth, and OpenID Connect.
SAML: A specific protocol that supports SSO but also enables broader identity federation.
Flexibility
SSO: Technology-agnostic and can work with modern standards like OpenID Connect in addition to SAML.
SAML: Primarily used in traditional enterprise environments and scenarios requiring high interoperability.
Implementation Complexity
SSO: May involve multiple protocols and configurations depending on the systems being integrated.
SAML: Requires a deeper understanding of XML and identity federation but offers consistent interoperability.
Security Strength
SSO: The security of SSO depends on the chosen protocol and implementation.
SAML: Offers strong security by keeping credentials with the identity provider and using encrypted tokens.
By recognizing these differences, organizations can better align their identity and access management strategies with their business needs.
How are SSO and SAML typically used?
Both SSO and SAML play significant roles in authentication and authorization, but their applications vary depending on organizational requirements:
SSO in Enterprise Environments:
Employees use SSO to access productivity tools, internal systems, and cloud applications without re-entering credentials.
Examples: G Suite, Microsoft 365, and Salesforce.
SAML in Federated Systems:
SAML is common in industries like education, healthcare, and government, where multiple organizations need secure access to shared resources.
Examples: Accessing third-party research platforms or shared industry databases.
SSO for Consumer Applications:
Businesses offering consumer-facing services use SSO to improve user retention and satisfaction by enabling login via social media accounts.
Examples: Social logins powered by OAuth or OpenID Connect rather than SAML.
SAML for Third-Party, Partner and Supplier Integration:
Companies use SAML to connect with external partners or vendors securely.
Examples: Allowing outside contractors to access internal systems without storing their credentials in the organization’s directory.
Many organizations leverage combined use of SSO powered by SAML for internal and external users. This ensures a consistent experience while supporting high security. Each of these use cases highlights the importance of selecting the right identity and access technology mix to meet specific organizational demands.
Conclusion
SSO and SAML are foundational technologies for modern identity and access management, addressing critical needs for security, efficiency, and user convenience. By understanding their distinctions and applications, businesses can create seamless and secure authentication environments that support growth and innovation. Choosing the right tools and strategies to leverage SSO and SAML effectively will position organizations to thrive in an increasingly interconnected digital landscape.
Want to learn more about access and identity security?
Discover more ‘what-is’ content and learning resources, including ebooks, guides and webinars, crafted to help you enhance your organization's access security strategy.